Top 5 Best Propane Smokers of 2023 [Review & Buying Guides]

Are you looking to get started smoking your favorite types of meat, but don’t have the luxury of a large outdoor smoker? If so, then finding one of the best propane smokers for your needs is absolutely essential!

Propane smokers are great for anyone who wants to effortlessly smoke food indoors or outdoors without having to spend too much on an expensive piece of equipment. With their easy setup and convenience in usage, these devices can provide delicious results with minimal effort required on your part.

In this blog post we will be exploring some of the leading propane smokers available today and comparing their features across all price points – allowing you to find just what works best for you and gives you the tastiest smoked foods possible!

Top 5 Best Propane Smokers of 2023 Reviews 

If you’re in a hurry? Please check out the top 5 best propane smokers on the market in 2022. Keep reading to discover more about our top picks.

RankImageProduct NameEditor's Opinion Price on Amazon
1Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane SmokerBest Overall
2Masterbuilt MB20051316 Propane SmokerRunner Up
3Camp Chef Smoke Vault 24" Vertical SmokerAmazon Choice
4Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36" Vertical LP Gas Smoker
Best Double-Door
5Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU-Infrared Smoker Roaster & Grill
Best Budget
6Broil King 923617 Smoke™ Vertical Natural Gas Cabinet SmokerHigh End Pick

1.Best overall: Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Smoker

The Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Smoker is the perfect size for patios and barbecue kitchens. It has a 5.45 square foot interior, making it spacious enough to smoke a variety of meats along with several trays of vegetables. The vertical footprint makes it perfect for small spaces.

The perfect way to get that delicious smoky flavor in your food! This smoker features a 36″ tall design, allowing plenty of space to cook multiple items at once. Additionally, the two doors and rear vent provide optimal access and control over the amount of heat and smoke exiting the oven.

This smoker features a porcelain enamel steel tray that holds wood chips and water, making clean-up easy after use. The smoker also has a side door that allows you to easily add wood chips when grilling.

The Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Smoker is the perfect smoker for those who want to enjoy delicious, slow-cooked food without breaking the bank. This smoker features four 14 x 14 in removable stainless steel grill racks, providing a total cooking area of 784 square inches – plenty of space to smoke your favorite meats and vegetables.

Specs for Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Smoker 

Brand: Cuisinart

Power Source: Propane

Dimensions: 19.3 x 18.1 x 38.6 inches

Weight: 69.5 pounds

Cooking Area: 785 square inches

Racks: 4

Power: 12,000 BTUs

Pros

  • Long propane hose
  • Thermometer on the door
  • Suitable for many spaces, even tight ones
  • The door is tightly sealed and there is no smoke leakage.

Cons

  • Only one door

Who else recommends it? The Cuisinart Vertical Propane Smoker has been recommended by multiple sources.

What do buyers say? 86% of 8,000+ Amazon reviewers rated this product 4 stars or above.

2. Masterbuilt MB20051316 Propane Smoker

The new Masterbuilt propane smoker is here! This time around, they’ve added some great features like thermostatic temperature control and gas flow monitors for more accurate smoking meat. You can get four chrome coated racks that will allow you to smoke up 792 square inches of food at once on either the large or extra-large size model – we recommend getting this if your plan includes churning out full packer briskets or ribs as it saves money by being smaller than their previous models (plus there are still plenty leftover).

Masterbuilt MB20051316 Propane Smoker offers a variety of cooking options, including high heat and fast paced cuisine. You can cook anywhere between 180 to 350°F which is perfect for low or slow smoking when you want crisp skin on your chicken pieces!

There’s also an sensor that shuts off the flow if it detects flames has beenextinguished so this will be handy especially during windy days since accidents happen easier with these types conditions

The stainless steel burner is perfect for even heat distribution. It puts out 15,7500 BTU with the help of an extra diffuser above it to make sure you get all your food cooked evenly!

Specs for Masterbuilt MB20051316 Propane Smoker

Brand: Masterbuilt

Dimensions: 22.8 x 28.7 x 53 inches

Weight: 92 pounds

Cooking Area: 961 square inches

Racks: 4

Power: 15,750 BTUs

PROS

  • Extremely Accurate Temperatures
  • Convenient fuel gauge
  • Easy to operate, Convenient 2 Door Access
  • Can smoke 6 large turkeys simultaneously

CONS

  • Masterbuilt has a limited warranty that you can use to get your product replaced if it ever breaks. I’ve never had the need for this, but at least there’s always protection!

3. Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36″ Vertical LP Gas Smoker

The Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36″ Vertical LP Gas Smoker. This smoker provides a whopping 784 square inches of cooking space, so you can smoke large quantities of food at once. Plus, there are four adjustable steel wire racks, so you can customize the cooking space to suit your needs.

It features a 15,000 BTU cast iron burner with an electronic push button ignition, and a large control dial that makes it easy to set the temperature.

This unit features a porcelain enameled steel wood chip box with handles and lid, so you can easily add your choice of wood chips for flavor. Plus, the porcelain enameled steel water bowl helps keep your food moist and juicy.

The Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36″ Vertical LP Gas Smoker is the perfect addition to your outdoor cooking arsenal. With its easy to use double-door design, you’ll have complete control over your smoking and cooking temperatures. The sliding air dampers on top and sides give you the choice of smoked or cooked heat control options, while the decorative temperature gauge with decor ring adds a touch of style to your smoker.

Looking for a smoker that will last you for years to come? Look no further than the Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36″ Vertical LP Gas Smoker. This smoker is built to last with a black stainless steel exterior and powder-coated surface. The high-heat paint won’t scratch, fade, or rust after years of heavy usage.

Specs for Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36″ Vertical LP Gas Smoker

Brand: Dyna-Glo

Power Source: Propane

Dimensions: 27 x 19.2 x 46.5 inches

Weight: 54 pounds

Cooking Area: 784 square inches

Racks: 4

Power: 15,000 BTUs

Pros

  • Spacious smoker box
  • Surface color fastness with time
  • Two doors.
  • Four Adjustable Racks

Cons

  • Quite heavy

4. Best Portable: Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer

 

The Big Easy is more than just a smoker. It’s a grill and a roaster, too, which makes it an excellent option for those on a budget or who lack the patio space for multiple appliances.

This grill uses TRU-Infrared technology to deliver even cooking results every time. Whether you’re cooking a large roast or a small steak (turkey, ribs, roast,…) this grill will ensure that your food is cooked to perfection.

The Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer is product holds up to 16 lbs for roasting, and has 180 square inches of cooking area for grilling.

The Char-Broil Grill is perfect for those who want to add a little extra flavor to their grilling. With its temperature control from 9,000 to 16,000 BTU’s, you can smoker box for added flavor without worry.

The Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer is the perfect cooking solution for those who want it all. This versatile grill features two large handles for easy transport and storage, making it perfect for small spaces. The Big Easy uses infrared technology to cook food evenly and efficiently, meaning you’ll never have to worry about under or overcooked food again. With a 23.5-inch tall design and less than 29-pound weight, this grill is also perfect for tailgating, camping or picnicking.

Specs for Char-Broil Big Easy TRU-Infrared Smoker Roaster & Grill 

Brand: Char-Broil

Power Source: Propane

Dimensions: 16.3 x 20.8 x 23.5 inches

Weight: 29 pounds

Power: 16,000 BTUs

Pros

  • Great for beginners
  • Convenient carrying handles and flexible

Cons

  • This is a small cooking appliance that does not include a propane tank.

5. Broil King 923617 Smoke™ Vertical Natural Gas Cabinet Smoker

If you have a big budget then this is the one for you

The Broil King 923617 Smoke Vertical Natural Gas Cabinet Smoker is perfect for those who love to barbecue. With 15,000 BTUs of power, it can handle even the biggest cookouts.

This smoker has plenty of space, with four adjustable stainless steel cooking grids and a multi-purpose rib/roast rack. The Roto-Draft cast aluminum damper system ensures even heat distribution, while the Accu-Temp thermometer lets you keep track of the temperature inside the smoker.

The extra-large water bowl and smoker tray make it easy to add flavor and moisture to your food, and the 16 integrated meat hooks make it easy to keep everything organized. The four sturdy tool hooks are perfect for hanging your barbecue tools, and the convenient bottle opener will come in handy when you’re ready to relax with a cold drink.

The heavy-duty doors have silicone gaskets and premium latch systems to keep the heat in, and the double-walled steel construction ensures even cooking. The Broil King 923617 Smoke Vertical Natural Gas Cabinet Smoker is available in propane and natural gas models.

The Broil King Vertical Natural Gas Cabinet Smoker also comes in a black finish that will look good when placed along with other outdoor cooking appliances and furniture.

The reason why we should consider investing into this product is its ease-of use, which makes it easier for anyone to operate regardless if they have little experience using propane smokers or not.

Specs for Broil King 923617 Smoke Vertical Natural Gas Cabinet Smoker

Brand: Broil King

Power Source: Natural Gas

Material: Aluminum,Stainless Steel,Steel

Item Weight: 73 Pounds

Item Dimensions: 28.5 x 25.5 x 48.5 inches

Pros

  • Easy to assemble
  • This grill is excellent quality
  • the ability to use charcoal.

Cons

  • High price
  • There is no timer or digital settings on this high-end model

You might be interested: Top 8 best smokeless indoor grills on 2022

What is a Propane Smoker?

A propane smoker is a type of smoker that uses propane as its main heat source. Propane smokers are popular because they’re easy to use and relatively affordable.Propane smokers typically have four main parts: the base, the smoking chamber, the heat source, and the chimney. The base is where the propane tank is located. The smoking chamber is where the food is placed. The heat source is what heats the smoking chamber and cooks the food. The chimney allows smoke to escape from the smoker.

Propane smokers come in a variety of sizes and styles. Some are designed for outdoor use, while others are meant for indoor use. There are also portable propane smokers available on the market. No matter what type of propane smoker you choose, be sure to read the instructions carefully before use.

Propane smokers are a great way to enjoy smoked foods without having to deal with the hassle of using a charcoal grill. If you’re looking for an easy-to-use smoker that will give you delicious results, then a propane smoker is a good option for you.

What Should You Look For In A Propane Smoker?

When choosing a propane smoker, there are several things you should keep in mind. First, consider the size of the smoker. If you plan on smoking large cuts of meat, then you’ll need a larger smoker. However, if you only plan on smoking smaller items like fish or chicken, then a smaller smoker will suffice.

Next, think about how often you plan on using the smoker. If you only intend to use it occasionally, then a lower-priced model may be all you need. However, if you plan on using the smoker on a regular basis, then you’ll want to invest in a higher-quality model that will last longer and provide better results.

Finally, consider your budget. Propane smokers range in price from around $100 to over $1,000. Decide how much you’re willing to spend on a smoker before beginning your search. This will help you narrow down your options and find the perfect propane smoker for your needs.

Factors to consider before buying Propane Smoker:

The size of the smoker: propane smokers come in a variety of sizes, so it’s important to choose one that’s big enough to accommodate your needs. If you’re only smoking small amounts of food, a small smoker will suffice. But if you plan on smoking large quantities of meat, a larger smoker will be necessary.

The price: propane smokers can range in price from around $100 to over $1000. Obviously, the more expensive smokers will offer better features and durability. But if you’re on a budget, there are still some great options available.

Durability: when choosing a propane smoker, make sure to pick one that’s built to last. Some cheaper models are made with inferior materials and won’t stand up to the rigors of regular use. Opt for a smoker made with high-quality stainless steel or aluminum for the best results.

Ease of use: some smokers can be quite complicated to use, while others are very simple. If you’re not familiar with how smokers work, it’s probably best to stick with a simpler model. But if you have some experience, you might want to consider a more feature-rich smoker.

Warranty: finally, make sure to check the warranty on the propane smoker you’re considering. Some companies offer longer warranties than others, so it’s worth checking before making your purchase. A good warranty will protect your investment and ensure that you’re happy with your purchase for years to come.

Follow these tips and you’ll be sure to find the perfect propane smoker for your needs. Enjoy smoking your favorite foods, and impressing your friends and family with your culinary skills!

When buying a Propane Smoker, keep these 3 things in mind: 

1. Number Of Doors

The best kind of smoker is one with a 2 or more door design because it provides better temperature control and allows you to add wood chips without sacrificing your water supply. You’ll also want an adjustable latch for this type model in order make sure that there’s no leaks during use

2. Capacity

The size of your smoker will depend on how many people you typically cook for and what kind of event or dinner menu item it is. If this includes a family that consists only three members, then there’s no need to get an entire large-sized propane smoker with six cubic feet interior space since they would be too much food for one person at any given time; however if hosting parties where everyone comes over than more hands are needed (and thus taller smokers may become necessary). For smaller units such as 18 inch wide ovens – 30″, 40″ versions come ready made outfitted from factory floor up so factor those dimensions into pricing decisions before making purchase

3. BTUs

When shopping for a smoker, it’s important to pay attention not only the size of your grill ( BBQs come in different sizes) but also what kind and how many BTUs its burner produces. The more energy-efficient models will have between 10 – 20 thousand units per hour while smokers designed specifically towards cold smoking require much lower amounts like 2500 or less on average; this difference can make all the difference if you plan on using these particular types often!

Now that you know the different factors that you need to consider before buying a propane smoker, you can start your search for the perfect one. Make sure to compare the prices and features of different smokers before making your final decision. This way, you can be sure that you are getting the best value for your money.

Types of Propane Smoker

Before deciding on which type of propane smoker is best for you, it is important to understand the different types that are available. The three most common types of propane smokers are vertical, offset, and cabinet.

1. Vertical propane smokers: These smokers have a tall, slender design and offer good temperature control. They’re perfect for smoking smaller quantities of food.

2. Cabinet propane smokers: These smokers are larger and offer more space for smoking large quantities of food. They’re also easier to use, thanks to their cabinet design.

3. Portable propane smokers: These smokers are small and lightweight, making them perfect for taking on the go. They’re not as durable as other types of smokers, though.

4. Electric propane smokers: These smokers use electricity to power the heating element, meaning they’re more energy-efficient than other types of smokers. They can be more expensive, though.

5. Gas propane smokers: These smokers use gas to power the heating element. They’re more expensive than electric smokers, but they’re also more energy-efficient.

No matter what type of smoker you choose, make sure it has good temperature control and is made from high-quality materials. Also, check the warranty before you buy. a good warranty will protect your investment and ensure that you’re happy with your purchase for years to come.

 Benefits of using Propane Smokers over other smokers:

1. Propane smokers are more convenient: Propane smokers are more convenient than other types of smokers because you don’t have to worry about starting a fire or adding wood chips. Just turn it on and you’re ready to go.

2. Propane smokers are easier to use: Propane smokers are also easier to use than other types of smokers. There’s no need to worry about temperature control or adding wood chips. Just set it and forget it.

3. Propane smokers produce less smoke: Propane smokers produce less smoke than other types of smokers, so they’re perfect for indoor use.

4. Propane smokers are more portable: Propane smokers are also more portable than other types of smokers, so they’re perfect for tailgating and camping.

5. Propane smokers are less expensive: Propane smokers are also less expensive than other types of smokers, so they’re a great option if you’re on a budget.

Propane smokers have many advantages over other types of smokers. Just make sure to choose the right model for your needs and you’ll be able to enjoy delicious smoked food anytime, anywhere

How to Use a Propane Smoker

Now that you’ve chosen the perfect propane smoker for your needs, it’s time to learn how to use it. Begin by reading the instructions that came with your smoker. This will teach you about the different parts of the smoker and how to operate it safely.

Next, take some time to practice using the smoker. Experiment with different smoking techniques and foods to get a feel for how the smoker works. Once you’re comfortable using the smoker, you’ll be able to produce delicious smoked foods with ease.

When you’re ready to start smoking, begin by preheating the smoker according to the instructions. Once it’s warmed up, place your food in the smoking chamber and close the lid. Allow the food to smoke for the amount of time indicated in the recipe or instructions.

Once the food is cooked, remove it from the smoker and enjoy! With a little practice, you’ll be able to master the art of smoking and produce mouth-watering smoked foods that will impress your family and friends.

Smoking food is a great way to add flavor and dimension to your dishes. If you’re looking for a unique cooking method, then smoking is definitely worth considering. By following these tips, you can learn how to use a propane smoker like a pro and produce delicious results. So what are you waiting for? Get started today and see what all the fuss is about!

As you can see, there are many things to consider when choosing a propane smoker. Keep these tips in mind and you’ll be sure to find the perfect smoker for your needs. With a little practice, you’ll be smoking like a pro in no time!

How Does a Propane Smoker Work?

1. The first thing you need to do is choose the right type of smoker for your needs. There are many different types of smokers on the market, so take your time and choose carefully.

2. Once you’ve chosen the right smoker, it’s time to get it set up. Make sure you read the instructions carefully so that you know how to set it up correctly.

3. Once your smoker is set up, it’s time to start smoking your food. The most important thing to remember is to keep an eye on the temperature. You’ll need to adjust the heat as necessary to ensure that your food doesn’t get overcooked or burned.

4. When your food is cooked, it’s time to enjoy the fruits of your labor! Sit back, relax, and enjoy the deliciousness that is smoked food.

5. Clean up your smoker when you’re done so that it’s ready for next time. Make sure to follow the instructions carefully so that you don’t damage the smoker.

Propane smokers are a great way to enjoy smoked food. Just make sure you choose the right type of smoker for your needs and that you follow the instructions carefully. With a little practice, you’ll be a pro in no time!

Common mistakes when using Propane Smoker:

1. Not preheating the smoker: One of the most common mistakes people make when using a propane smoker is not preheating the smoker. This can cause the meat to cook unevenly and result in an inferior product.

2. Not adding enough wood chips: Another common mistake people make when using a propane smoker is not adding enough wood chips. This can also cause the meat to cook unevenly and result in an inferior product.

3. Adding too much wood: Another common mistake people make when using a propane smoker is adding too much wood. This can cause the fire to smolder and produce a lot of smoke, which can be unpleasant and even dangerous.

4. Not monitoring the temperature: Another common mistake people make when using a propane smoker is not monitoring the temperature. This can cause the meat to overcook or even catch fire.

5. Not cleaning the smoker: Another common mistake people make when using a propane smoker is not cleaning the smoker. This can cause the build-up of soot and ash, which can be unpleasant and even dangerous.

Avoid these common mistakes and you’ll be able to enjoy delicious smoked food anytime, anywhere.

Tips for smoking meat with a Propane Smoker:

1. Choose the right type of meat: The first step to smoking meat is to choose the right type of meat. There are many different types of meat, so make sure you select one that will taste good when smoked.

2. Prepare the meat: Once you’ve chosen the right type of meat, it’s time to prepare it for smoking. This may involve trimming the fat, marinating it, or adding a rub.

3. Select the right wood: The type of wood you use will affect the flavor of your smoked meat. Make sure you select a wood that will complement the flavor of the meat you’re smoking.

4. Set up your smoker: Before you start smoking, you’ll need to set up your smoker. This usually involves adding wood chips to the firebox and preheating the smoker.

5. Smoke the meat: Once your smoker is set up, it’s time to start smoking the meat. Make sure you keep an eye on the temperature and add more wood chips as necessary.

6. Enjoy your smoked meat: When the meat is cooked, it’s time to enjoy it! Serve it with your favorite sides and enjoy the deliciousness that is smoked meat.

7. Clean up your smoker: When you’re done smoking, make sure to clean up your smoker so that it’s ready for next time.

Smoking meat is a great way to add flavor to your food. Just make sure you choose the right type of meat, prepare it properly, and select the right wood. With a little practice, you’ll be smoking like a pro in no time!

 How to care for your Propane Smoker so it lasts for years:

If you’re a fan of smoked meats, then you know that propane smokers are the way to go. They’re easy to use and produce amazing results. But like any other cooking appliance, they need to be properly cared for in order to function at their best. Here are a few tips on how to care for your propane smoker:

1. Read the manual that came with your smoker carefully. This will help you understand how your particular model works and what you need to do in order to maintain it.

2. Clean your smoker regularly. A build-up of grease and food particles can cause your smoker to work less efficiently and can also lead to safety hazards.

3. Inspect your smoker before each use. Make sure that there are no leaks in the fuel lines and that all of the connections are tight.

4. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for lighting your smoker. This will help prevent any accidents.

5. When you are finished smoking, be sure to turn off the gas supply to your smoker. This will help prevent any fires from occurring.

By following these simple tips, you can ensure that your propane smoker will provide you with years of enjoyment.

Recipes for smoked meats that will wow your taste buds:

1. Smoked brisket: This smoked brisket recipe is mouth-watering and full of flavor. It’s perfect for a special occasion or a casual get-together.

2. Smoked ribs: These smoked ribs are finger-licking good! They’re perfect for a summer cookout or any time you’re in the mood for some delicious BBQ.

3. Smoked chicken: This smoked chicken recipe is juicy and full of flavor. It’s perfect for a quick meal or to feed a crowd.

4. Smoked salmon: This smoked salmon recipe is healthy and delicious. It’s perfect for a light meal or as an appetizer.

These are just a few of the many recipes available for smoked meats. So get creative and try something new! Your taste buds will thank you.

FAQs:

1. What type of meat should I smoke?

There are many different types of meat that you can smoke, so it really depends on your personal preferences. Some popular options include beef, pork, chicken, and fish.

 2. Why should I choose a propane smoker over wood, charcoal, or electric models?

Propane smokers offer many advantages over other types of smokers. They’re easy to use, produce consistent results, and are very versatile. So if you’re looking for a smoker that’s easy to use and produces great results, a propane smoker is a great option.

3. How long do propane tanks last?

Propane tanks typically last for about 20-40 hours, depending on the size of the tank and the smoker. So if you’re planning on smoking for several hours at a time, you may need to purchase multiple tanks.

Smoking meat is a great way to add flavor and tenderness to your favorite cuts of meat. And with a propane smoker, it’s easy to get great results. So if you’re looking for a new and exciting way to cook your favorite meats, give smoking a try! You won’t be disappointed.

4. What’s the difference between cold and hot smoking?

Cold smoking is a process of flavoring meat without cooking it. This is typically done at lower temperatures for a longer period of time. Hot smoking, on the other hand, is a process of both cooking and flavoring meat. This is typically done at higher temperatures for a shorter period of time.

5. Can you use a gas grill as a smoker? 

Yes, you can use a gas grill as a smoker. However, it’s important to make sure that you purchase a grill that’s specifically designed for smoking. This will ensure that your food is cooked properly and evenly.

6. What are the major differences between a gas and electric smoker? 

The biggest difference between gas and electric smokers is the heat source. Gas smokers use propane or natural gas as a heat source, while electric smokers use electricity. Electric smokers are typically more expensive than gas smokers, but they’re also easier to use and maintain.

7. How Long Does a 20lb Propane Tank Last on a Smoker?

A 20lb propane tank will typically last for about 20-40 hours, depending on the size of the smoker and the temperature at which you’re smoking. So if you’re planning on smoking for several hours at a time, you may need to purchase multiple tanks.

8. How Hot Does a Propane Smoker Get?

Most propane smokers will reach temperatures between 200-250 degrees Fahrenheit. However, some models are designed to reach higher temperatures. So if you’re looking for a smoker that gets very hot, make sure to check the specifications before purchasing.

9. What wood should I use for smoking?

The type of wood you use will affect the flavor of your smoked meat. Some popular options include hickory, mesquite, and apple. Make sure you select a wood that will complement the flavor of the meat you’re smoking.

10. How long do I need to smoke the meat?

The amount of time you need to smoke the meat will depend on the type of meat and the desired results. For example, if you’re smoking chicken, you’ll need to smoke it for less time than if you’re smoking beef.

11. What temperature should I smoke the meat?

The ideal temperature for smoking meat varies depending on the type of meat. For example, chicken is typically smoked at a lower temperature than beef.

Final Verdict on Best Propane Smoker

All in all, if you are looking for a smoker that is easy to use and provides great results, Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical (Best Overall) is the way to go. We’ve looked at some of the best propane smokers on the market and found that the ones that run on propane offer the most convenience and versatility. Not only do they provide an even cook every time, but they are also very affordable when compared to other types of smokers. So, if you are ready to take your smoking game up a notch, then be sure to check out one of the propane smokers on our list.

Leave a Comment